I'm going to be pretty harsh in this review but I think the broader context justifies it.
Yes, this burger looks beautiful. Gaucho does not publish any professional photos of it online for some reason but even crappy Google Maps user submitted photos reveal it to be quite the looker. And believe you me, those buns are as good as they look.
That's where my high praise mostly ends.
This is a very bougie burger. Comes in a very small portion for an absurd amount of money. As such, I would have expected the dish I received to be perfect. And in theory it kind of was: the buns, the patty, the veggies, and the sauce (more on that below) are all on point in terms of quality. But the patty was grilled well done. Despite the fact I ordered it medium rare. And despite even the fact that it says right on their damn menu that all their beef is grilled medium. Promises made, promises broken.
But that was unfortunately not even the most disappointing thing about this burger.
That dubious honor belongs to the sauce. Was it bad? No. Perfectly adequate, actually. Too adequate. It tasted so predictable that it immediately let all the air out of my enthusiasm. In a burger this expensive, a "perfectly adequate" sauce is, in my all but humble opinion, not an acceptable state of affairs.
I'm not anti-pricey burgers. I make that abundantly clear in many reviews and in my Standards article. But that cost has to be borne out somewhere. The most obvious place for that would be truly exceptional meat or actually unique sauce(s). The meat's temp was overshot and the sauce tastes exactly the same as on burgers for 2/3 the price. So what is a man to do?
Bottom line: in a vacuum, as a food product and nothing else, it's good. But if you step outside of the vacuum and want a burger, I encourage you to take a few more steps. Specifically, about two minutes worth of steps, until you arrive at Pop's Place, a much better bougie joint.

The reviews, names of restaurants, dishes, and images appearing on this website are fictitious.
No identification with actual sandwiches (dead or alive) or their creators is intended or should be inferred.
Site and design © 2022 - 2026 FatherOfAlways ™